2/10 Just another Edinburgh hotel now, save your money and stay elsewhereNice enough, read negative comments for full experience
Kerri-anneFeb 17, 2025
4/10 Disappointed in communicationThe hotel is so clean and beautiful. The location is fantastic. Staff are amazing and friendly.
StewartMar 10, 2025
10/10 Five star elegance and treatment!What a remarkable and pleasurable experience The Caledonian offered us!
This hotel has elegance, beauty, charm and “positive energy” that is contagious. All of the staff were exceptionally accommodating, professional and personable. Laura was not only friendly and genteel, she also was efficient, as were Erin, Catherine and Amy! The bellmen Mr. George, Michael and Mark always greeted us with a smile and helping hand as well as local knowledge. The spa masseuses, Sondra and Denise, were delightful and made sure we had a most relaxing spa experience.
Thank you to “The Caley” family for completing our Scotland journey in Edinburgh. It was a five star experience!
747ameliahMar 12, 2025
10/10 PerfectAfter being placed in a newly refurbished room, which met all the booking requirements and was very elegant, the smell of fresh paint was still quite strong. After directing concerns to the night concierge team Shaleigh and Danny, they very promptly found us a solution and even went through the personal touch of making sure the new room was perfect before offering it up as an alternative. Saved a lady, who is very uncomfortable complaining with a friendly smile and resolution. Would highly recommend even purely if only for mthe customer service you get 24 hours. An awkward situation resolved without an awkward interaction. We will be back.
TarynMellyMar 16, 2025
8/10 Nice stay but didn't love itI have wanted to stay at this hotel for a while so decided to treat myself. It was lovely, but wasn't amazing.
Stunning building with very helpful staff.
Room was very nice and bed was comfy.
Breakfast was great. Very high quality and set me up for the day.
JasonMar 27, 2025
9/10 Wonderful restful stayStaff helpful and very friendly. Room was spotlessly clean. Comfortable bed. Although you can be next to a busy road the traffic noise (from the 4th floor) was not a problem. Really like the how the hotel has developed the space between the two old buildings and created a lovely bright lounging area.
GurdialFeb 27, 2025
10/10 Another fantastic stay at this delightful hotelThis was our 2nd time staying at this lovely hotel and again it did not disappoint. We had a great surprise at check in when we were told we had a complimentary upgrade. Our room was extremely well appointed and I loved trying out the dyson hairdryer. We thoroughly enjoyed relaxing in the lounge and listening to the live music and enjoying some delicious cocktails and fine wine. The breakfast was superb with a great variety to choose from and of good quality. We cannot wait to return to this friendly luxurious hotel
G4922MEjudithbMar 15, 2025
10/10 It’s a “wow” factorWow. As a Diamond member, loved the perks this hotel offered (spa, gym, upgrade, breakfast, and more). Our room view was amazing, it’s 10/10 worth the castle view. The rooms are European sized, so all you US folks don’t be surprised, it’s efficient and cozy. If you’re in your room a lot, why did you travel all the way to EDI?
The Court for lunch is 100/10, the staff, the food, the piano is worth the stop.
We were so pleased by our visit. Can’t wait to come back.
Kbeveridge22Mar 12, 2025
10/10 Wonderful stayThis was my first time staying at the Caledonian. The hotel has a great location for sightseeing and convenient access to public transportation. The room was spacious and very clean, with a super comfy bed. The breakfast was fantastic, a buffet with a huge selection of delicious foods and beverages. The staff was very helpful and kind. Big shoutout to Yulia for being so wonderful and accommodating! I highly recommend this property.
GaliaMar 3, 2025
1/10 Disappointing. We felt 2nd class having paid for first.Lovely powerful shower
DouglasMar 20, 2025
10/10 A perfect short stay in the city. We shall return.Staff were exceptional. For example the concierge, when asked about a pre-ordered newspaper went to a nearby newsagent and bought us The Times. The waitress at breakfast remembered our order of the previous day even though she had only served us once. Help with taxis was very welcome.
Breakfast and afternoon tea menus were perfect.
Room was clean and well serviced.
KevinFeb 25, 2025
10/10 Good place to stay but try other bars and restaurants although peacock alley is nice for a drinkClean, tidy, friendly staff, comfortable rooms, right in Edinburgh centre.
PaulaFeb 23, 2025
9/10 Lovely hotel, well located friendly staffLovely hotel, stunning building and great location. We had a basic room on this occasion but was clean and kept tidy by daily servicing.
LilyFeb 18, 2025
7/10 Great hotel , but room not up to the cost .Good location and staff good
GillianMar 9, 2025
7/10 Beautiful building but disappointing roomThe Court bar area was stunning and staff were very friendly. A beautiful building.
TracyFeb 23, 2025
9/10 Great City to visit with loads to do and great hospitality.Staff were very friendly and facilities were very good in deed. Room was recently refurbished so couldn't of asked for anymore. Breakfast was excellent as were the choices of bars in the hotel and the Spa was great
BenMar 4, 2025
8/10 Good location and pleasant modern roomHave stayed here several times and it is a good location and has good facilities with modern rooms.
JenthorpeMar 11, 2025
7/10 GoodExcellent location for our needs.
JudithFeb 25, 2025
10/10 greatGreat experience having drinks at the Caledonian! such lovely and helpful staff and the most delish and unique cocktails!! Would definitely recommend going for a drink there :) The atmosphere is so lovely and the bar area has a beautiful piano which is played on certain days of the week. Altogether a 10/10 experience!
L1863BMivylMar 12, 2025
10/10 The staff made every effort to make our day special!Absolutely fantastic. We stay here once a year and got married here on 15th. The staff were excellent. The standard of service was 10 out of 10! The food and wine for the wedding party was excellent. You made our wedding day so special!! See you next year! Thank you
PatriciaApr 16, 2025
8/10 Comfortable and affordable luxuryThe bed was comfortable, the room had a great view, the tea and coffee making facilities in the room were good, the TV was great and the bathroom toiletries were lovely.
MadelineFeb 17, 2025
9/10 SuperbThe hotel is lovely food excellent staff excellent . Very clean modern mixed with old . Close to all amenities.
PatriciaFeb 18, 2025
4/10 Hoyel was lovley. Most staff were pleasant but the room was a terrible value for moneyThe food was lovley.
AndrewFeb 20, 2025
4/10 Disappointed with the roomGood location. OK premises. Has potential…
YiannisApr 21, 2025
10/10 Cannot wait to go back and stay.The Hotel had a fantastic presentation, the staff were more than helpful and the facilities were world class.
DanielMar 12, 2025
10/10 perfect.Ideal city break with hotel in ideal location and all main attractions in walking distance. Highly recommend.
GordonMar 3, 2025
5/10 would have loved to try nice room,very disapointed with one we hadlocation very good,staff very nice.
LeeApr 1, 2025
8/10 A thoroughly enjoyable stayThe room was very good. Location was excellent . We did not pay for main buffet breakfast but in The ~Court (menu was limited but good.
JosephineMar 25, 2025
8/10 wonderful staff at every step of the way and a great location, we will use this hotelThe staff and the location
MattMar 19, 2025
10/10 ExceptionalAmazing hotel! Excellent location and the room was very comfortable too. The breakfest was a bit limited compared to the quality of the other services the hotel offered. Either way, would definitely go back for the location and overall hotel accomodations.
LauraApr 14, 2025
8/10 Romantic and perfectsuch a beautiful building surrounded by so much to do, amazing places for food, a stones throw away from the grassmarket and beautiful views of the castle
SarahFeb 16, 2025
7/10 Goodthe cleanliness, aesthetic and friendly staff!
PaigeFeb 16, 2025
10/10 The staff were exceptional , especially Amy. Beautiful hotel.Our room is very spacious, very comfortable bed and pillows. The food from room service was delicious.
AnnaMar 2, 2025
9/10 Location was great, we had a lovely stay staff where very helpful only downside that I didn’t realise was the spa was ouIt was a lovely building
NicolaFeb 25, 2025
10/10 We were a group of 4 males on a meet-up to celebrate the end of a project we have been working on together. We stayed 2Excellent location and characterful building.
GarethMar 15, 2025
10/10 Perfect StayLocation was perfect for visiting all the attractions of the city. The room was very comfortable and had everything you needed and more for a city break.
ShonaFeb 28, 2025
10/10 Excellent night away, enjoyed every minute.Beautiful Hotel, Very friendly staff - given upgrade on arrival
AnitaApr 15, 2025
9/10 Little bit of luxury amid the bustleExcellent location, beautiful hotel and facilities. Very pricey- but to be expected for location in a popular city
GinaApr 6, 2025
10/10 Stayed over as a treat for our Granddaughter. Staff made a great memory for her, cannot thank them eExceptional, a brilliant experience
HeathMar 23, 2025
10/10 An amazing location and luxury hotel experienceGreat location. Beautiful rooms . Great food . Friendly staff
JackieApr 20, 2025
9/10 Great value and superb standards.Great sized room
AndrewMar 11, 2025
9/10 SuperbBeautiful grand building
ChristopherApr 22, 2025
10/10 Very comfortable room which was great after a full day and night of activities and sightseeingDecor beautiful, ideal location, excellent breakfast, helpful and pleasant staff
LorraineFeb 20, 2025
10/10 Hotel reviewLocation was perfect and very friendly staff
AndyFeb 16, 2025
10/10 Super stay in a lovely with attentive staffBeautiful large room
AndreaFeb 20, 2025
10/10 Amazing stay thank you!The staff were incredible with our son thank you so much!!
WilsonMar 8, 2025
9/10 Short one nigt stay but very good expeienceVery central in terms of location
JayakumarMar 6, 2025
10/10 ExceptionalSpa and food. Exceptional caring staff. Can't wait to come back
DavieMar 5, 2025
10/10 Relaxing break in EdinburghA huge choice all fresh and great quality
OfflerApr 7, 2025
10/10 Great nights sleep !!Great location. Huge room. Very quiet.
WendyMar 12, 2025
7/10 Breakfast v expensiveThe position and bar
NorrishApr 20, 2025
10/10 Beautiful hotel, friendly staff, great room, spa was great
AshleyMar 26, 2025
10/10 ExceptionalEverything was amazing
LorraineApr 7, 2025
10/10 ExceptionalEverything literally
OrhanFeb 20, 2025
8/10 Very goodGreat location.
VernApr 16, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
MulliganApr 17, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
AshleyApr 11, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
TonyApr 10, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
RichardApr 6, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
StuartMar 27, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
LynnMar 27, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
JacobMar 23, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
AbogaziaMar 22, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
SuzanneMar 21, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
HelenMar 16, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
NicolaMar 13, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
PedroMar 12, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
AnnMar 10, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
StewartMar 8, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
ShelleyMar 7, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
MarkusMar 3, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
CassieFeb 28, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
IanFeb 25, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
KaraFeb 25, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
DarrenFeb 25, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
ChuckyFeb 23, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
BrettFeb 22, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
PaulFeb 20, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
WendyFeb 18, 2025
8/10 Very good
NicolaFeb 19, 2025
5/10 Passable
NilimaApr 20, 2025
9/10 Superb
MaryApr 19, 2025
9/10 Superb
ÇağlaApr 14, 2025
9/10 Superb
AndyApr 3, 2025
9/10 Superb
DiarmuidMar 31, 2025
9/10 Superb
EdwardMar 31, 2025
9/10 Superb
AnneMar 23, 2025
9/10 Superb
GwanwynMar 20, 2025
9/10 Superb
KerryMar 14, 2025
9/10 Superb
PaigeMar 11, 2025
9/10 Superb
AlanMar 10, 2025
9/10 Superb
SharonMar 10, 2025
9/10 Superb
Oisin1000Mar 8, 2025
10/10 Superb
PaulMar 3, 2025
9/10 Superb
NicolaFeb 27, 2025
9/10 Superb
WendyFeb 18, 2025
7/10 Good
McknightMar 10, 2025
1/10 Bad
NaitriFeb 23, 2025