1/10 Unfriendly, unclean, would not stay here againThe location was great and right next to Penn Station, which is very central.
PoppyApr 14, 2025
4/10 Except for the location, barely a 3 star experienceCan’t beat the location. And the price is reasonable compared to other hotels for a basic place to stay.
PaulApr 9, 2025
10/10 Great hotel in a fantastic locationJust returned home from a great stay here, my first visit to NYC! Front desk let us check in 2 hours early with no extra charges - was really grateful for this after the 10 hour journey from Scotland. We stayed in a standard Metro queen room and it was on the small side as expected in NYC but it was fine for us. We didn't spend much time in our room anyway! We even had a nice little view :) Facing the "Edge" at Hudson Yards. Bed was perfectly comfortable. Drawers and a cupboard with hangers meant we could unpack some clothes. Shelf in bathroom for toiletries & toothbrushes plenty clean towels supplied. The room was very warm for us woke up very hot during the first nights sleep but we were able to adjust heat on thermostat which worked well. All staff we engaged with were very friendly. Elevators were very quick. We were able to leave our suitcases at the hotel on final day for $5 per piece (as shown on their website) as we were not flying home til 8pm. Hotel is in a great location so close to public transport links. Would stay here again 100% if I was fortunate enough to come back to NYC!
lynsayc2025Mar 18, 2025
4/10 DisappointingWe stayed here for 5 days and the location is the main advantage of the hotel, nothing to add about that.
I don’t know if that’s a habit in the US but there was no coffee/tea provided neither a kettle in the room.
The room is smaller than the impression on the pictures, but that’s okay. However, we had an issue with the toilets where water was leaking. We complaint but the issue hasn’t been fixed during our stay.
Also we had to pay 5$ PER suitcase for storage the last day since our train was in the evening. I find that expensive.
TeodorApr 5, 2025
9/10 Overall, really enjoyed our stay and would not hesitate to stay there again for our next trip.Location was excellent. The room was a good size (Executive Double), the noise level in the hotel was very quiet (there was street noise but that's to be expected). The Tick Tock Diner and the Butcher and Banker restaurants in the hotel were very good. There were plenty of elevators and we never had to wait more than a few seconds and they were never crowded.
JasonApr 6, 2025
7/10 If it was good enough for Nikola Tesla, it's good enough for me :-)Perfect location - within walking distance of Broadway, Times Square, even Central Park, and many other attractions, right across the street from Penn Station and near Port Authority bus terminal, easy access to subway. Lobby is nice. The reception staff let us check in about one hour earlier. Comfy bed. Convenient closet with a safe. Several nice restaurants on site.
VesnaApr 8, 2025
10/10 Perfect Location for a Visit to NYCCan't beat the location, imo! Not in Times Square, but just beyond it (literally next door to Madison Square Garden); across the way from Penn Station, so transportation was very easy! The room was very clean (and cleaned every day - vacummed, bathroom cleaned; beds made; new towels), and we had a great view! I was with my 16 year old daughter for her first trip to NYC, and she loved it. It made me feel better that there were always security guards at the elevators to check to be sure the people admitted to that area were actually guests. Front desk staff was very friendly and helpful. Rates were reasonable for the location and amenities. Highly recommend!
646martyrMar 19, 2025
9/10 Great stay, great hotel!Amazon hotel. Great location. Subway & train station few steps away. We were offered an upgrade by booking.com a few days before & took it to upgrade to family suite. We got the Muhammad Ali room! Lots of space but the bathroom definitely needs a revamp. Paint peeling off the walls & bath tub. Shower had four very powerful jets that didn’t make for a comfortable shower. That’s my only criticism. Beds were really comfy, not too much city noise ( we were on floor 25) and rooms warm. Staff were helpful when we needed them. Would definitely recommend this hotel.
NicoleApr 6, 2025
10/10 A New Yorker experienceI love staying here, my room had a beautiful view to the city, location couldn't be better, staff was very friendly! I like the way they keep the vintage style of the hotel, and that makes it very special, but i think a remodeling was needed: the doors have some cracks from the paint, the toilet in my room was a little rotated from the wall, etc. Just a few details I think needed attention.
Overall I love staying here, I love my little room with the most amazing view (at night even better!)
Thank you The New Yorker!!
A.Apr 7, 2025
10/10 Great Place to Stay and Great Value in NYCTerrific location in the heart of NYC! An older hotel with character that is clean. Stayed on 23rd floor but elevators are very quick and half of the elevators service floors 1-20 and other half cover 21-40, so really not a long ride was ever felt. Felt very safe as hotel staff check to make sure you have room key/ are definitely a hotel guest, before boarding the elevator. Towels are clean and fluffy. Beds comfortable. Great having Tik Tok Diner available 24 hours a day.
679jeanninebMar 18, 2025
9/10 Lovely art deco hotel close to lotsWe decided to stay here as an easier option for early flight on day we left. It’s so close to subway, which is complex but a faster way to get around. Some New Yorkans, think New Yorker, is a bit old and stale. It’s the last art deco hotel in New York, it's got character. It’s also close to Times Square and Empire State Building. Elijah on front desk was lovely, he checked in. Jibri on tour desk, was also lovely and helpful.
HelenApr 5, 2025
6/10 Could be better stay.Hotel is an old establishment, no updates, so enjoy the nostalgia feeling. Provided a taxi pickup from airport to hotel, a nice service.
AngieApr 11, 2025
5/10 PassableLocation wise it was ok, close to everything, although it it is not the nicest NYC location. Room was basic, small, outdated - but clean and for a night or two ok.
ViktoriaApr 7, 2025
8/10 Starting Wedding Journey in New York - hidden fees!Cant fault the staff or the location.
The additional faculty fee is a con! Should be explained at check-in.
So disappointed by the response when queried my bill.
Make sure you are fully made aware of what all the charges that can be added on to your bill you ask at check-in, as they are quick to up-sell you.
Thanks
379leeannmMar 18, 2025
10/10 You will need something to help with the “normal noises” of this city. For one reason, they called the city that never sLocation is PERFECT. If you want to be closer to the principal tourist places in New York, this hotel is perfect.
MarlyApr 12, 2025
6/10 Great locationGreat location next to Penn station.
Highly recommend Essen restaurant, which is like a huge buffet either eat in or take away.
Walking distance to many sightseeing site e.g Empire state building, Time Square.
The hotel although clean does need a full renovation.
Had a queen sized room and probably the smallest room and bathroom staying in.
PeteApr 7, 2025
10/10 Fantastic location - spectacular viewsFantastic stay and staff were amazing and accommodating. We got to stay on one of the suites on floor 38 which had breathtaking views of the entire city from our room. Whilst it does need a little updating in places, the hotel is a lovely little treasure in itself with a rich history of its own. Highly recommend it.
RichardApr 14, 2025
9/10 A great choice for our last night in Manhattan.Beautiful Building and great location. The staff at the desk were helpful, friendly and informative. The room was fine…. A little small, but all we needed for one night.
We were delighted to find it was just a short walk to MTA. One stop on the LIRR then Air Train to JFK…. So easy!
JillApr 5, 2025
10/10 The perfect place to stay while enjoying the sights and energy of New YoExcellent location and exceptionally friendly staff. The hotel had everything we needed, and everything went smoothly. The hotel offers stunning views of the city skyline, which could make your stay even more enjoyable. We had a great time and will definitely be coming back.
AmeliaApr 5, 2025
6/10 Pleasant
LeeanneApr 12, 2025
7/10 Despite some things that I don't like, the location and the view was excellent!The location. The view from 37th floor - Amazing! The room pretty clean, and a very confortable bed.
AlexandruApr 8, 2025
8/10 Fantastic location which is great if just using as a place to crash.Great location. Subway is super convenient. Room was fairly small but to be expected in the heart of manhattan. Only thing I wasn’t a fan of was that you had to show your room key every time you used the elevator which was more of an inconvenience than anything.
JohnApr 6, 2025
8/10 A good hotel with a shocking policy towards storage of luggageGreat hotel in a perfect location with helpful staff. However being charged $5 per bag to store luggage before check in and after checkout is an effrontery. The price of hotels in New York is expensive enough that this should not be included as a separate item.
JamesApr 13, 2025
6/10 The hotel doesn't have parking! They sent me to another building and I was charged extra for parkingThe location is good.
JuanApr 11, 2025
9/10 5 Night Stay for GAA gameThe location of the New Yorker is perfect and is conveniently accessible from JFK on the Subway. The front desk staff are efficient and security at the hotel is top class. A special mention to the ladies on the 24th floor who did a top class job servicing the room during my 5 night stay
SenanApr 8, 2025
10/10 Great position. Extremely clean.Old hotel charm in an excellent position to travel all around NY. The subway stations are very close. The staff were excellent, the room was extremely clean. The bed was good. Security was good. I felt safe. I’d definitely stay there again. Very good.
angelalS9850MCMar 18, 2025
8/10 Small rooms, dated hotel in the heart of the city.Landmark hotel and diner with tasty breakfast. Starbucks on bottom floor, centrally located in midtown for Times Square, show, restaurants, long walk to Central Park museums. Staff always pleasant. Hotel is dated, rooms small for price.
MoniqueApr 6, 2025
10/10 Best location in old hotel.Dated hotel with Tik Tok diner with tasty breakfast. Starbucks on bottom floor, subway/Penn Station outside door, centrally located in midtown for Times Square, Broadway, restaurants, long walk to Central Park museums. Staff always pleasant.
MoniqueApr 6, 2025
5/10 Rooms were comfortable, location excellent, common areas eg corridors in urgent need of upgradesit brings down the overaLocation, staff, cleanliness
BridgetApr 11, 2025
6/10 Great location if you want to be close to Penn Station and Madison Square Garden.Proximity to Madison Square Garden and Penn Statuon.
JenniferApr 11, 2025
7/10 GoodGreat location, friendly staff, ok breakfast, several restaurants in hotel, good security concept with access control
FriedrichApr 7, 2025
9/10 Dated hotel close to it all.Very dated hotel with landmark diner with tasty breakfast. Starbucks on bottom floor, centrally located in midtown for Times Square, show, restaurants, long walk to Central Park museums. Staff always pleasant.
MoniqueApr 6, 2025
7/10 GoodLocation was excellent. Our room was comfortable, and while small, it ticked all our needs for the few days. Took us a while to find the sockets - so for anyone else: they're built into the clock thing on the bedside table!
GemmaApr 10, 2025
6/10 MehLocation is amazing. The diner downstairs is great.
JessicaApr 7, 2025
10/10 Perfect location for a few days in New YorkThe convenience of everything. Staff so friendly from Reception to Porter to staff in Diner.Everything was good.
AgnesApr 7, 2025
7/10 GoodExcellent location. Easy to access subway and get to main attractions. Good size room.
JdmistryApr 7, 2025
9/10 Fantastic LocationCramped with 2 adults and 2 kids in a room and very dated but a perfect base for exploring NYC! Location was amazing! Staff were friendly and helpful. Views of the Empire state building!
RossApr 8, 2025
8/10 Fair PRICE and GREAT LOCATION!!!The location is PERFECT as it is minutes from Time Square and RIGHT DOWN the street from Madison Square Gardens.
TaneshaApr 14, 2025
10/10 PeacefulLocation es perfect I traveled by train. High floor nice view. Shower pressure great. Clean room. No disturbances.
JairusApr 14, 2025
5/10 PassableThe location was great the staff was nice and friendly
BridieApr 12, 2025
7/10 Excellent location for a great priceIt's located near Penn station so you couldn't ask for a better location.
For the price there are not much better options.
Wi fi is not great.
AndréApr 7, 2025
9/10 New York was amazing and the New Yorker Hotel was a great place to stay.The staff was very helpful and the room was perfect for the two of use!
KendallApr 8, 2025
5/10 PassableRoom not serviced - nothing! Given I had booked a further two nights, that was unsatisfactory. Room was well serviced next day following my complaint.
MonicaApr 7, 2025
10/10 FantasticBeautiful views of the New York City skyline from our room. The beds were very comfortable. The staff were very friendly and helpful. I will be back.
NorrieApr 12, 2025
8/10 PleasantGood location.
Rooms quite small.
Was woken up at 5:30am to a man banging and trying to open our room door- thankfully we had the lock on the door!
KatieApr 10, 2025
7/10 It was fine for the money.Location
StacyApr 14, 2025
9/10 SuperbLoved the location. Perfect for walking to everything I needed in the city.
SamApr 7, 2025
8/10 Amazing stay in New Yorker!Location was ideal and staff very helpful
NatalieApr 15, 2025
6/10 Great location but tired and dated roomsLocation was great
RachaelApr 7, 2025
10/10 nice stay for a weekI think it was perfectly fine to stay at the hotel. Very close to everything we wanted to see. Will be back soon.
KjellApr 5, 2025
1/10 BadThey have not returned the deposit despite many emails sent without response ! bad customer service, never consider this hotel !
MajedApr 13, 2025
5/10 It's doing its job as a decent value because of the location.It is very old. The rooms are small, and the shower is uncomfortable.
YuvalApr 15, 2025
8/10 Recommended as a good place to stayGreat central location next to Penn St. hotel was nice and clean, facilities a little dated
HeatherApr 10, 2025
10/10 Best location ever and affordable.Best hotel you can find in the best location for the ideal price. Look no more. Recommended
ArielApr 5, 2025
7/10 Centrally located - Functional for a short stayLocation
Price
RonenApr 7, 2025
10/10 I stay here often and always enjoy my stay.The Tic Tock Diner
KatherineApr 12, 2025
2/10 Very poorFound a needle on the floor of my room, also the beddings had very large stains in them.
AliApr 7, 2025
8/10 Great HotelFantastic location.
LizanneApr 5, 2025
10/10 Great base location for our NYC tripGreat location and friendly staff
JamesApr 7, 2025
9/10 SuperbCentral location / room was always clean / staff was friendly
RatiApr 8, 2025
6/10 PleasantGood location.
NikolaiApr 9, 2025
6/10 PleasantGreat central location.
EoghanApr 7, 2025
7/10 Good location very noisy with construction in hotel
JamesApr 11, 2025
10/10 ExceptionalThe staff were amazing, and the location was perfect.
AlexApr 5, 2025
10/10 ExceptionalNice hotel 🏨 and excellent location.
FernandoApr 7, 2025
9/10 FantasticLocation
BernardApr 5, 2025
8/10 Very goodGreat hotel in a perfect location
DanielApr 7, 2025
8/10 Fantastic location-Close to everything!
JoannaApr 7, 2025
6/10 PleasantBest location, room very small
GianlucaApr 5, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
AmieeApr 13, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
JenniferApr 11, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
MarkApr 8, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
Snow01Apr 7, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
JonApr 7, 2025
10/10 Exceptional
GaryApr 7, 2025
8/10 Very good
SnehaApr 11, 2025
8/10 Very good
BarbaraApr 10, 2025
2/10 Very poor
ChristianApr 10, 2025
8/10 Very good
KerryApr 9, 2025
8/10 Very good
BaderApr 9, 2025
8/10 Very good
StefanApr 9, 2025
8/10 Very good
IrinaApr 7, 2025
8/10 Very good
AracelyApr 7, 2025
8/10 Very good
FiacraApr 6, 2025
8/10 Very good
BerelsonApr 5, 2025
6/10 Pleasant
ArtemApr 13, 2025
5/10 Passable
JoeyApr 8, 2025
5/10 Passable
ShakeyaApr 7, 2025
6/10 Pleasant
MatthewApr 6, 2025
9/10 Superb
RazaApr 14, 2025
9/10 Superb
HazelApr 12, 2025
9/10 Superb
ChrisApr 9, 2025
9/10 Superb
MahmoodApr 7, 2025
9/10 Superb
YuvrajApr 7, 2025
9/10 Superb
HernandezApr 7, 2025
9/10 Superb
IrinaApr 7, 2025
9/10 Superb
MarieApr 6, 2025
9/10 Superb
LarryApr 6, 2025
9/10 Superb
RaysaApr 5, 2025
7/10 Good
McgeeApr 11, 2025